Second Hand Heart (original and SUNO)
So here's something I could never pull off on my own -
a 60s Motown girl group pastiche
Original Demo:
https://soundcloud.com/sean-swindler/17-second-hand-heart-09-1
SUNO version:
Comments
-
Again, this is apples to oranges. Suno will always sound polished — that’s what it’s programmed to do. Honestly, I prefer your version because of the rawness and emotional weight. It’s your emotion that makes the track resonate. Suno may simulate feeling, but it’s not real — it’s emulated. That’s the difference between your song and Suno.
It really depends on where you want to take these tracks. If this is just a hobby, Suno is a great tool — polished, quick, and fun to experiment with. But if you’re serious about making money, then put your version into a DAW, add some backing vocals, and you’ve got something you can sell. The difference comes down to ownership and marketability: your own recordings are fully yours, while Suno is better suited for hobby/demo use.
0 -
It does depend on what you want to use it for, but I like how these are coming out.
If the idea is to capture what you had in your mind when writing the song, then I think these are really working for you. And it's nice to hear that polished version. Neither you nor I are going to get there on our own.
But as always, it's your opinion that matters! :)
0 -
I left you a comment on Suno. It will do you more good there than here.
0 -
At times the vocals seemed a little out of place with the overall sound, but then everything was fine! I'd like to read the lyrics... I haven't heard Suno's version; I'm only interested in yours.
0
Howdy, Stranger!